Joel Talks – Pool Service Q&A: Filtration

With over 22 years of industry experience, our Service Manager, Joel Fitzgerald, has seen a lot! This week, he’s sharing information on pool filtration.

Customer Question: “Which pool filter is best to use?”

Answer: When it comes to filters for your pool and spa, there are a few options, but basically three main choices. Which one should you choose? Let me define them for you. This list will not be a “best to worst” list, as different environments are suited for different filters, but I will list them in order of micron size capture from least to most.

  1. Sand filters: Sand filters have the lowest filtration when it comes to particle size, capturing particles around 20–100 microns, and most use silica sand media. You might think, “Why would anyone ever want a sand filter?” Ease of use is the most common reason. The sand bed is typically good for 2–8 years, depending on a good backwash routine and minor environmental influences.The sand filter is often the filter of choice in commercial settings because of this. There is no need for bi-annual filter cleans or damaged cartridges/grids. These filters come with a backwash valve that allows the user to reverse the flow through the filter and flush everything it has filtered out of the pool down a backwash line, either into the yard or into a drainage or sewer line.

    The backwash cycle is extremely important on a sand filter and should be done between 1 and 3 minutes. As you can imagine, this will drain a good amount of water from the pool, so it is very important to keep the water level up when you expect to perform a backwash cycle. If done improperly, you can actually reduce filtration by creating channels through the sand bed that allow debris to go straight back into the pool.

    Areas that are prone to high winds and blowing sand are best for this filter, as those conditions can be a bit too harsh for other filter choices. The filter will show you that it is time to change the sand by clouding up the pool. Depending on the sand filter size, changing the sand can be a daunting task, but innovations and synthetic products have made this a lot easier than in the past. Products like Ruby Sand can cut the media needed in half. Please remember, silica sand is considered hazardous material and should be disposed of properly. You definitely do not want to add it to the sandbox!

  2. Cartridge filters: Cartridge filters are a step above sand filters in particle size filtration, capturing particles around 10–20 microns. Cartridge filters are by far the most popular filter choice because they are the best of both worlds.There is no need for backwash valves, the cartridges can handle most loads, and they are generally recommended for bi-annual cleaning. Most cartridge filters come in a four-cartridge setup and can be easily removed and cleaned by anyone who can watch a YouTube video.

    The lifespan of filter cartridges is typically 4–5 years, but it is not uncommon to stretch that out longer. With more frequent cleanings, doubling the life can be easily obtained. The gauge on top of the filter will keep you informed as to how they are doing, but there are also visual cues, usually seen at the spa when the spillover slows down from what it usually is, or when there is reduced flow in the pool in general.

  3. Diatomaceous Earth filters: These are the kings when it comes to particle size filtration, with the ability to capture particles down to around 3–5 microns. If you’ve ever turned your pool lights on at night and seen floating particles in the pool, this is the filter for you.This filter also comes with a backwash valve because it uses diatomaceous earth, or DE, as the filter media. The DE coats the filter grid or cartridge and captures particles as the water passes through and returns to the pool. Backwashing flushes out the dirty DE, and you then need to add DE back to the filter to replenish what was washed out.

    Done deal, you say? Why would I choose any other filter if this is so great? Not so fast, my friend! While DE filters are amazing at what they can do, they are also the most finicky of the three. The DE powder is like talcum powder, and when something goes wrong in the filter, you can turn a crystal-clear pool milky white in no time.

    Also, while you have the ability to backwash and extend the cleaning cycle of the filter, it still needs to be taken apart bi-annually to be completely cleaned. General maintenance can be harsh on the internals, so be ready to dig into your wallet. Some municipalities and HOAs do not allow DE filters, so be sure to check before having one installed.

All in all, every type of filter available for your pool and spa will get the job done. Visiting with a pool professional about expectations and limitations will help create a happy match between your filter choice and poolscape for years to come.

Do you have questions you’d like help with from Joel? Give us a call at (281) 351-2577 and ask for him by name, or send us an email at info@poolmaninc.com. Let’s see what we can do to help make pool ownership fun instead of a high-maintenance worry!